ManCaveExpert.com is reader-supported. If you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Buffalo Bills Man Cave

Buffalo Bills Man Cave: 11 Must-Have Items

Whether you are looking to spruce up your Buffalo Bills man cave or you’re looking for the perfect gift for a Bills fan, these products are sure to get the job done. From the Bills of the AFL, to the Jim Kelly led Super Bowl teams of the 90’s, to Josh Allen and the newest generation of Bills, we have something for everyone.

1. 1963 Boston Patriots Vs Buffalo Bills Metal Sign


This replica of the program cover from the Bills – Patriots 1963 AFL Eastern Division Playoff game recreated on a retro looking tin sign is a great way to add a vintage look to your Bills man cave. Measuring 8 x 12 inches, the sign will fit easily on any wall. With great retro graphics, and “War Memorial Stadium” prominently displayed on the program, this sign is perfect for fans of an older generation.

CHECK PRICE

2. Buffalo Bills Man Cave Heavy Duty Steel Street Sign

If you want to leave no doubt that you’re about to enter the man cave of a Bills fan, this street sign fits perfectly above a doorway entrance. Made in the USA with heavy duty embossed steel, this officially licensed sign is top quality.

CHECK PRICE

3. Framed Bruce Smith Autographed Jersey

If novelty signs aren’t cutting it for you, level up your Bills man cave game with this fully matted and framed autographed Bruce Smith jersey. At almost 3 feet tall and 3 and a half feet wide, this is sure to be the centerpiece of your man cave. Holding the NFL record for most career sacks at 200, Smith was the defensive leader of the 1990’s Bills who went to 4 straight Super Bowls. The autographed jersey comes with a certificate of authenticity from James Spence Authentication (JSA), one of the most respected companies in the industry.

CHECK PRICE

4. Buffalo Bills Throw Pillow Covers

Add some Bills flair to your couch pillows with these throw pillow cases. Made of 100% high quality polyester, they are durable and machine washable for when your friend spills his bleu cheese while screaming at the refs. Let your wife pick the throw pillows in the living room, but don’t make sure to keep the flower print out of your man cave.

CHECK PRICE

5. Joe Journeyman Buffalo Bills 500-Piece Team Puzzle

This Bills team puzzle is a great addition to put on the coffee table in your man cave. The puzzle features the Bills stadium surrounded by Bills fans and iconic Western New York landmarks including Niagara Falls. The final puzzle is a Where’s Waldo style search and find game. After you complete the puzzle, find Journeyman Joe among the crowd. Best of all, 10% of profits from the sale of the puzzle goes to Joe’s Kids charity and local children’s hospitals.

CHECK PRICE

6. NFL 3D StadiumView Bills Stadium Coasters

YouTheFan NFL 3D Team StadiumViews 4x4 Coasters - Set of 2, Buffalo Bills, 4" x 4", Team Color

Whether they call it Rich Stadium, The Ralph, or Bills Stadium, your guests will be happy to put their beer down on these 3D replicas of the Bills home field. Keep ugly can and bottle marks off your coffee table while adding to the aesthetic of your Bills man cave.

CHECK PRICE

7. Josh Allen 2018 NFL Draft Pick Bobblehead

Add some fun to the shelves in your Bills man cave with this Josh Allen bobblehead. This highly detailed bobblehead features the Bills quarterback after getting drafted seventh overall by the Bills in the 2018 NFL Draft. Forever Collectibles is known for their highly detailed high quality figures.

CHECK PRICE

8. You Gotta Know Buffalo – Sports Trivia Game


This Buffalo sports trivia game features 150 trivia cards with 600 Questions about Buffalo sports. Not exclusively a Bills trivia game, there are also questions about the Sabres, Bisons, local college teams, and more. Each question is a assigned a point value based on difficulty, making it east to play the “race to 21” games. Or you could just sit around your man ca e and try to answer the questions with your friends.

CHECK PRICE

9. Buffalo Bills Billieve Flag

What Bills Mafia man cave would be complete without a Buffalo Bills flag hanging on the wall? Its large size (measuring 3 x 5 feet) and vibrant colors make a nice addition to any empty space on your man cave wall. Officially licensed by the NFL, you can be sure that it’s a quality flag meant to last especially indoors.

CHECK PRICE

10. 100 Things Bills Fans Should Know & Do Before They Die

Full of trivia about Bills franchise history, players, and coaches, this Bills book is the perfect coffee table book for your Bills man cave. Brush up on your knowledge of your favorite team during commercial breaks and settle debates with your friends. Written by author Jeff Miller who is a member of the Professional Football Researchers Association and a Western New York local.

CHECK PRICE

11. Legends Never Die Jim Kelly Framed Photo Collage

No Bills man cave would be complete without the greatest quarterback in franchise history. Jim Kelly led the Bills to 4 straight Super Bowls while quarterbacking one of the most exciting offenses of the 1990’s – the K-Gun. Set in an 11” x 14” frame, this display showcases an 8” x 10” photo of Kelly along with a smaller 3” x 5” photo and a short bio of the Bills legend.

CHECK PRICE

No matter what your budget is, this list of products is sure to have something that will improve your Buffalo Bills man cave. Go Bills!

Other AFC East Man Caves

  1. Miami Dolphins Man Cave
  2. New England Patriots Man Cave
  3. New York Jets Man Cave