Indianapolis Colts Man Cave

Indianapolis Colts Man Cave: 9 Must-Have Items

The Indianapolis Colts have two Super Bowl Championships under their belt and can typically make the playoffs, unlike some other teams around the country. So supporting them in your Indianapolis Colts man cave is easy! Plus, if you have never been to Lucas Oil Field Stadium then you are missing out!

While they did struggle for the 22/23 season they usually come back strong so don’t worry!

We have gathered some information on some of the must have items you should have in your man cave. Some are no brainers but some will enhance your Colts man cave to the next level.

Show off your fandom with these must-have memorabilia items for your Indianapolis Colts Man Cave.

1. Lucas Oil Stadium View

YouTheFan NFL 5-Layer 17 x 13 StadiumViews 3D Wall Art

Home to the Indianapolis Colts since 2008, this 3D wall art features an incredible view of the stadium, made of five layers of wood construction. Featuring team colors and impeccable detail, the display is easy to hang and measures 17” x 13”.

2. Colts Stainless Steel Beer Coolers – Simple Modern

Of course, every man cave needs to have a variety of beer koozies. While watching the next game, enjoy using this cooler with your Colts colors. The set comes with a size for 12 oz aluminum beer cans and 12 oz skinny cans of beer or seltzers. Check the link below for the most up to date price.

We at man cave expert love the fact that these are so much cheaper than the overprice coolers that you find in the stores. You will almost pay double just for one.

The only negative about these coolers is that they do not fit bottles!

If you need a koozie that is personalized check out Etsy. The wrap below can be personalized with a name, and two other lines each allowing 22 characters. So if you are or you know someone that is a huge Colts fan then this might be fore them.

3. Customized Decanter and Glasses

Another customized Etsy item, this Decanter and whiskey glasses can add a little class to your man cave setup. You have the option to choose how many pieces you need. For example if you only need one glass or a Decanter and four glasses that is all possible with this order. You can even add a name or further text next to they symbol by coordinating with the Etsy seller BTWNYOUandME.

The whiskey glasses hold 10.25 ounces and the decanter holds 23.75 ounces.

Check out the link below and you will see some great reviews from Colts fans and some great photos of they personalized their glasses.

4. Indianapolis Colts Checkers Board Game

MasterPieces NFL Indianapolis Colts Checkers Board Game

Have fun with some game time of your own with this checkers board game featuring the Indianapolis Colts. The game includes a total of 24 checker pieces and eight football helmets to represent king pieces. Featuring realistic end zones and team colors, the board game measures 13” x 21”.

This is a great way to play games with your kids while showing off your love of the colts.

If you want to be creative you could probably use this as cool show piece when you put out food during the game or arrange the little helmets in a pattern while you are not playing with it. The options are endless.

5. Two Piece Colts Coaster Set

This coaster set by YouTheFan is perfect for keeping your man cave clean from beverage stains. The set includes two 3D coasters with a non slip back to make sure your drinks never slide. Made of high-quality materials, the detailed coasters protect wood, glass, marble, stone, and even stainless-steel tables from unwanted stains.

It is a simple way to get started on fan gear for your Colts Man Cave!

6. Colts Tiki Totem

Team Sports America NFL Tiki Totems (16 Inches, Indianapolis Colts)

Show off your Colts fandom with this awesome tiki totem. The hand-painted totem pole is hand-painted with the team’s colors and their team mascot, Blue, sitting on top. Standing 16” tall, this figurine is not only stylish and unique, it is sculpted from 100 percent resin with pristine wood-carving details.

7. Peyton Manning Super Bowl Plaque

Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl XLI Peyton Manning Plaque with Replica Ticket - NFL Player Plaques and Collages

One of the most loved Indianapolis Colts, quarterback Peyton Manning, must be featured in every Colts man cave.

Bringing the team a championship in 2006, Peyton Manning is celebrated with this collectible plaque. The display features a photo of Manning and a replica ticket of Super Bowl XLI.

The black plaque measures 12” x 15” and is the perfect way to honor the Super Bowl XLI championship team’s star quarterback. Remember champions, like Peyton, live forever!

8. Indianapolis Colts 2006 Super Bowl Champions Dynasty Banner

Winning Streak NFL Indianapolis Colts Dynasty Banner

Another way to celebrate the 2006 Super Bowl Champs is with this vintage style wool banner. The dynasty banner expresses emotion, excitement, and displays the ultimate level of Colt’s glory. Measuring 24” x 36”, the banner is ready to hang with a handy nylon cord.

9. Colts Wooden Barrel Wall Clock

FOCO Indianapolis Colts NFL Barrel Wall Clock

This wooden barrel wall clock is just what every man cave needs to keep track of time so you don’t miss a game. Made of 100 percent wood and hand-painted featuring the Colts logo and colors, it measures 11.9″L x 1.5″W x 11.9″H and requires AA batteries. The clock also comes with a hook at the top, making it easy to hang.

10. Peyton Manning Game Used Turf

This actual game turf from the days when Payton Manning captained the Colts is definitely a unique piece to have in an Indianapolis Colts man cave.

Here are the specs on this:

  • The artificial turf comes in a case and measures 2.5 inches x 3 inches
  • Peyton manning playing card accompanies the turf
  • Comes with a certificate of authenticity

Hang this turf up on the wall with the card and certificate or display it in a display case. There is no wrong answer to how to display this.  You will get a lot of questions and comments on this unique piece. The Turf comes from the RCA dome where Peyton Manning had 6 years to hone his craft before playing at the Lucas Oil Field house.


11. Joe Journeyman Indianapolis Colts 500-Piece Team Puzzle

YouTheFan NFL Joe Journeyman 18'' x 24'' 500-Piece Team Puzzle

This Colts puzzle featuring Lucas Oil  Stadium is a great addition to the coffee table in any Colts man cave. The puzzle features Indianapolis landmarks including the Soldiers & Sailors Monument from Monument Circle and Salesforce Tower. After completing the puzzle, search for Joe Journeyman in a Where’s Waldo style game. 10% of profits from the sale of the puzzle goes to Joe’s Kids charity and local children’s hospitals.

The Peyton Manning glory days may be over, but the Colts winning spirit is far from over. Whether you have an Indianapolis Colts Man Cave or are looking for gift ideas for a Colts fan, these items are sure to fit the bill.

Other AFC South Man Caves

  1. Houston Texans Man Cave
  2. Jacksonville Jaguars Man Cave
  3. Tennessee Titans Man Cave